Post by imperfectgolfer on Dec 1, 2012 0:59:54 GMT -5
See this BM video on his "tumble move".
Note that BM groupies think that BM is a genius - see this BM-forum thread.
www.brianmanzella.com/golfing-discussions/17870-video-answer-back-porch-tumble-drill-aim-primer.html
I am constantly flabbergasted at their lack of knowledge of golf swing mechanics. That "tumble motion" of the clubshaft is simply the natural way a golfer should move the club from P5.5 to P7 when he rotates the intact LAFW onto the impact zone's inclined plane.
Here is a photo sequence from my downswing chapter.
Keegan Bradley's downswing action
BM would label what Bradley Keegan is doing in image 3 a "tumble action". I think that it is simply the natural rotation of the clubshaft onto the impact zone's inclined plane. If you look carefully at Bradley's FLW, you will see that there is no tumbling motion of the hands or shaft per se - because the clubshaft is simply releasing within the plane of his LAFW when the FLW is parallel to the surface of the inclined plane. Note how simply and efficiently BK lowers his FLW (and intact LAFW) down to the elbow plane between P4 and P5.5 (images 1 and 2), so that the club can easily release onto the desired impact zone inclined plane as he bypasses the P5.5 position.
Here is the TGM instructor Rick Nielsen demonstrating this fundamental downswing motion using a rope.
Note how the rope transitions onto the impact zone's inclined plane as he transitions from image 4 to image 5 - note that Rick Nielsen keeps his FLW parallel to the surface of the inclined plane. Note that he performs a PA#3 release action in image 6 (stage 3 of the BM-described tumbling action).
If you are interested in a rational way of understanding this action - you could read Q&A 22 in my downswing chapter.
perfectgolfswingreview.net/downswing.htm
If you want to view a very comprehensive video-explanation of the virtues of playing golf with an intact LAFW then you could view this 90 minute video interview hosted by Ralph Perez - where I go into great depth about the subject.
The TGM concept of an intact LAFW (and understanding its motion in space) is much more rational than BM's simplistic/primitive "tumble" explanation.
Jeff.
Note that BM groupies think that BM is a genius - see this BM-forum thread.
www.brianmanzella.com/golfing-discussions/17870-video-answer-back-porch-tumble-drill-aim-primer.html
I am constantly flabbergasted at their lack of knowledge of golf swing mechanics. That "tumble motion" of the clubshaft is simply the natural way a golfer should move the club from P5.5 to P7 when he rotates the intact LAFW onto the impact zone's inclined plane.
Here is a photo sequence from my downswing chapter.
Keegan Bradley's downswing action
BM would label what Bradley Keegan is doing in image 3 a "tumble action". I think that it is simply the natural rotation of the clubshaft onto the impact zone's inclined plane. If you look carefully at Bradley's FLW, you will see that there is no tumbling motion of the hands or shaft per se - because the clubshaft is simply releasing within the plane of his LAFW when the FLW is parallel to the surface of the inclined plane. Note how simply and efficiently BK lowers his FLW (and intact LAFW) down to the elbow plane between P4 and P5.5 (images 1 and 2), so that the club can easily release onto the desired impact zone inclined plane as he bypasses the P5.5 position.
Here is the TGM instructor Rick Nielsen demonstrating this fundamental downswing motion using a rope.
Note how the rope transitions onto the impact zone's inclined plane as he transitions from image 4 to image 5 - note that Rick Nielsen keeps his FLW parallel to the surface of the inclined plane. Note that he performs a PA#3 release action in image 6 (stage 3 of the BM-described tumbling action).
If you are interested in a rational way of understanding this action - you could read Q&A 22 in my downswing chapter.
perfectgolfswingreview.net/downswing.htm
If you want to view a very comprehensive video-explanation of the virtues of playing golf with an intact LAFW then you could view this 90 minute video interview hosted by Ralph Perez - where I go into great depth about the subject.
The TGM concept of an intact LAFW (and understanding its motion in space) is much more rational than BM's simplistic/primitive "tumble" explanation.
Jeff.