Post by imperfectgolfer on Sept 15, 2013 19:45:26 GMT -5
Now that BM's golf forum has become private (GolfWiseGuys) we don't regularly get exposed to stupid BM groupie comments. However, occasionally BM posts a post in his BM golf forum, which reminds me of his stupidity and BM groupie stupidity.
See - www.brianmanzella.com/golfing-discussions/18324-trying-straighten-right-arm-early-downswing.html
Here are some hilariously stupid comments.
BM - "As far as the right arm goes, you massively add TUMBLE/Beta (pitch of the club) torque at left arm parallel in the downswing."
BM - "At the Golf Magazine Top 100 Summit last year, I was presenting on several topics and one of them was "tumble" Two top teachers just couldn't wrap their heads around it. "I don't see it," was what they said.
But it is there.."
BM - "You want an initial force along the shaft—tangential to the hand path—this will be assisted by the right arm straightening early, 'away from your left ear". ---- "the golfer is applying force along the shaft "away from the left ear" by pivoting and by straightening their right arm early."
---- How early? In these three PGA Tour player AMM right arm graphs provided by Tyler Ferell, one of them does it right away. One keeps it bent for about a tenth of a second, one adds bend about that long.
Then, all three of them massively, quickly, violently, straighten the dog doo-doo out of their right arms toward impact. ----- It is my contention that the golfer is trying to straighten the arm from the top, away from them, right away, early in the downswing, and depending on their rotational force from their pelvis and torso, actually straighten it massively at different places within a half of a tenth of a second differently "
Talk about imprecision in describing the right arm straightening action that happens between P5.5 and P7 (and not before P5.5 as BM asserts) and BM manifests that imprecision.
Wulsy asked-: "Why do many, eg David Toms get to impact with a really bent right arm? "
The WelshDentist replied-: "I would guess that when you reverse direction at the top and pulled hard the right arm would want to bend more, but by trying to straighten it it would not bend more or even straighten a touch"
That's amazingly stupid! He then stated-: "If you stopped at the top then paused and did nothing but straighten the right arm, then feel like you apply that force then pulled down as well it activates the whole right shoulder/lat complex." Wow! Can you even try to imagine what the WD is talking about? If you think that's irrational, consider his next statement-: "I just see the right arm thing as a trying to, but not actually doing, more of a resisting the force wanting the increase the arm bend... He definitely wins the prize for the most stupid BM groupie commentary in that thread.
BM then decided to chime in and provide another explanatory comment-: "
Straighten - The process of making something straight.
To start with, the right arm is never really dead straight. It would hurt. Secondly, it is really bent at the top—and on the way to how ever much it gets straight, you hit the ball.
Wow! So, now that comment is supposed to make it become understandable - you have a really bent right arm at the top, and then you hit the ball on the way to how ever much it gets straight. Only a BM groupie can appreciate the wisdom (actually lack of wisdom) of that imprecise advice.
This BM-forum thread shows the BM/BM groupies clowns at their best - providing comic relief to non-BM groupies.
Jeff.
See - www.brianmanzella.com/golfing-discussions/18324-trying-straighten-right-arm-early-downswing.html
Here are some hilariously stupid comments.
BM - "As far as the right arm goes, you massively add TUMBLE/Beta (pitch of the club) torque at left arm parallel in the downswing."
BM - "At the Golf Magazine Top 100 Summit last year, I was presenting on several topics and one of them was "tumble" Two top teachers just couldn't wrap their heads around it. "I don't see it," was what they said.
But it is there.."
BM - "You want an initial force along the shaft—tangential to the hand path—this will be assisted by the right arm straightening early, 'away from your left ear". ---- "the golfer is applying force along the shaft "away from the left ear" by pivoting and by straightening their right arm early."
---- How early? In these three PGA Tour player AMM right arm graphs provided by Tyler Ferell, one of them does it right away. One keeps it bent for about a tenth of a second, one adds bend about that long.
Then, all three of them massively, quickly, violently, straighten the dog doo-doo out of their right arms toward impact. ----- It is my contention that the golfer is trying to straighten the arm from the top, away from them, right away, early in the downswing, and depending on their rotational force from their pelvis and torso, actually straighten it massively at different places within a half of a tenth of a second differently "
Talk about imprecision in describing the right arm straightening action that happens between P5.5 and P7 (and not before P5.5 as BM asserts) and BM manifests that imprecision.
Wulsy asked-: "Why do many, eg David Toms get to impact with a really bent right arm? "
The WelshDentist replied-: "I would guess that when you reverse direction at the top and pulled hard the right arm would want to bend more, but by trying to straighten it it would not bend more or even straighten a touch"
That's amazingly stupid! He then stated-: "If you stopped at the top then paused and did nothing but straighten the right arm, then feel like you apply that force then pulled down as well it activates the whole right shoulder/lat complex." Wow! Can you even try to imagine what the WD is talking about? If you think that's irrational, consider his next statement-: "I just see the right arm thing as a trying to, but not actually doing, more of a resisting the force wanting the increase the arm bend... He definitely wins the prize for the most stupid BM groupie commentary in that thread.
BM then decided to chime in and provide another explanatory comment-: "
Straighten - The process of making something straight.
To start with, the right arm is never really dead straight. It would hurt. Secondly, it is really bent at the top—and on the way to how ever much it gets straight, you hit the ball.
Wow! So, now that comment is supposed to make it become understandable - you have a really bent right arm at the top, and then you hit the ball on the way to how ever much it gets straight. Only a BM groupie can appreciate the wisdom (actually lack of wisdom) of that imprecise advice.
This BM-forum thread shows the BM/BM groupies clowns at their best - providing comic relief to non-BM groupies.
Jeff.